Current Interest Rates

The Federal Reserve has begun lowering short-term interest rates, as expected.  They started with a 1/2 percent cut and are expected to continue to lower rates through 2025.  Longer-term rates went lower in anticipation of these cuts, but have since gone higher. 

The 10 year US Note had gone below 3.65%, but is now sitting at 4.21%.  This can be attributed to stronger than expected economic data and concerns that neither candidate in next month’s presidential election seems concerned about the federal deficit or debt.

Looking at the data below makes me think that the best value right now is in intermediate and longer-term municipal bonds.  Interest from municipal bonds are typically free from federal taxes.  In almost all states, if you buy bonds in the state that you live, that interest is also not taxed.  I used a 30% total tax rate for the comparisons below, 24% Federal and 6% State.  The higher your income and tax rate, the more valuable that interest free income is worth.

 

Interest Rates That You Receive

1 Year5 Years10 Years20+ Years
US Government Bonds4.30%
4.07%4.21%4.62%
High Quality Municipal Bonds3.05%3.50%4.15%4.5%
Municipal Bonds- Tax Equivalent4.36%5.00%5.92%6.43%
CDs4.10%3.90%4.05%N/A
High Quality Corporate Bonds4.50%5.00%5.30%5.60%

Interest and Dividends From Funds

High Yield Corporate Bond Fund6.65%
Preferred Stock Fund6.07%
High Quality Dividend Stocks4.25%

Interest Rates That You Have to Pay

30 Year Mortgage6.75%
15 Year Mortgage6.00%
Credit Card APR23.37%

The Case for Individual Bonds

Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) are fantastic investment products that provide diversification at a relative low cost to investors.  These funds can hold stocks, bonds, real estate, gold, or about any kind of investment you can think of.  I use them for my clients and myself.  However, when it comes to fixed income products there are some important reasons to consider using high grade individual bonds and CDs for your portfolio.

Predictability:

When you buy an individual bond, you know much you’re paying for it, how much it’s paying you, and how much you will receive when the bond is due.  A steady stream of income can be created from several different individual bonds.  This predictability can be particularly valuable for retirees relying on bond income to cover living expenses. 

It is also helpful when you know a large expenditure is coming.  Whether that is buying a house, paying for college, or any large ticket item, individual bonds can take the guess work out of returns.  For example, you can buy a US Government Treasury or CD that comes due right before the date that you need the funds

Less Volatility:

Most bond funds have a target duration or time frame that they want to hold bonds.  For example, the fund may target bonds that come due in about 10 years.  To achieve is, they will usually own a collection of bonds that have 8 to 12 years until they are due.  As time goes by and a bond has less than 8 years left, it will be sold and replaced by a bond that has 10-12 years left.  They then go out and buy the best bonds for their fund.  They are at the mercy of where current interest rates are at the time. This can lead to more inconsistent returns. Most bonds funds that aren’t very short-term funds don’t hold any bonds to maturity.  This isn’t a criticism.  It’s just how those funds work.

The strategy of using individual fixed income products works best using Certificates of Deposit or very high grade bonds, such as United States Government Treasuries and highly rated Municipal and Corporate Bonds.  This greatly reduces risk of default.  When it comes to lower grade and higher yield bonds, diversifying is very important.  That’s why I do use ETFs for higher yield bonds.  That’s when it’s better to pay them a small fee to own hundreds, or thousands, of different bonds from different issuers.

Avoiding Fund Fees and Expenses:

Bond funds typically charge management fees and expenses, which can erode investors’ returns over time. Most of the bond ETFs that I use charge very low fees, but they can add up over the long term, especially in periods of lower interest rates or market volatility. By investing in individual bonds, investors can bypass these fees and improve their overall returns.

Conclusion:

Building a fixed income portfolio is like putting together a puzzle. How much income is needed? How will this income be taxed?  How much risk should I take?  Diversification provided by ETFs is integral, but allocating at least some of your portfolio to individual bonds will take out some of the guesswork when you’re trying to solve your income needs.

Generating Income with Covered Calls

As a financial advisor, I am always looking for ways to generate more income for my clients’ portfolios.  Bonds can be great income producing products and are usually quite stable.  The downside of bonds is that they don’t give investors any upside appreciation.  One investment strategy that can give you both growth and income is called a covered call strategy.   Trading options may sound intimidating, but they can be used to cut risk and to generate income in your portfolio.

What is a Covered Call?

A covered call is an options strategy where an investor owns an asset, typically shares of a stock, and sells a call option on that same asset. The call option gives the buyer the right to purchase the underlying asset at a predetermined price within a specified period. In return for selling this call option, the investor receives a premium, which they keep regardless of what happens with the option.

How Does it Work?

Let’s break down the covered call strategy with an example:

Apple stock is trading at $170.  You can sell an option to sell your Apple stock on July 19 for $175.  One option contract is 100 shares of stock.  You would receive $6.50 in premium from selling your option.  That gives you a 3.8% yield for 3 months.

PriceDollars
Buy 100 Shares of Apple17017,000
Sell 1 Contract- 175 Call 6.50650
3 Month Covered Call Yield3.8%

Possible Outcomes

If the price of Apple stock goes lower, your first 3.8% in losses is covered by the premium that you received from selling the option. 

If the price stays around $170, you will receive your 3.8% yield.  

If the stock rises to $175 or above, you may have to sell your shares at $175, even if the stock appreciates well above that $175 price.  Your total return would then be:

$5 appreciation on the stock (175-170) plus the $6.50 in option premium = $11.50.

That makes your 3 month return 6.8%.

Apple Stock Price at ExpirationPercentage MoveGain or Loss $Gain or Loss %
150-11.8%-13.5-7.9
160-5.9%-3.5-2.1
1700.0%+6.5+3.8
175+2.9%+11.5+6.8
185+8.8%11.5+6.8

What Happens after your Option Expires?

What happens after July 19 depends on where your Apple stock is trading as that date arrives.  If the stock remains below $175, you can choose to sell another option at a later date and continue to make this an income generator for your portfolio.  If the stock is trading above $175, you may have the option of buying back that option and rolling it to a further out date and/or price or you could simply sell your shares for $175 for a solid return.

Tax Considerations

Options are subject to the same holding period rules as other investments.  If options are held for more than a year, they are taxed at the long-term capital gains rate, 15%, or 20% for higher earners.  If options are held for less than a year, they are taxed as ordinary income.  There are some covered call funds that use Index Based Options that offer more advantageous tax rates.  They are typically taxed as 60% long-term and 40% short-term.  Covered calls are probably best used in retirement accounts due to their taxation, but also work just fine in taxable accounts.

The Downside of Covered Calls

Like with any other investment, there are risks and consequences to consider:

  1. Limited Upside: By selling a call option, you cap your potential upside if the stock price rises significantly above the strike price.
  2. Limited Downside Protection: In our example, you received a 3.8% yield. If your stock depreciates by more than 3.8%, you will lose money.  

How Can I Use Covered Calls?

This strategy can be used on individual stocks, indexes like the S&P 500, or Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs).  ETFs give you diversification of the underlying asset and, typically, monthly income.  Using individual stocks gives you less diversification but it can give you more options as to how far out in time and price you want to write your option.  This can be very effective for highly appreciated stock that you don’t want to sell for tax purposes, but would like to use to generate more income for your portfolio.

Writing covered calls is not meant to be a replacement for the equity portion of your portfolio, but it can be a great way to increase your income.  The income portion of your portfolio should have a diverse mix of income producing investments, especially as you move into retirement.

If you think that covered call strategies could fit into your portfolio or have any questions, please reach out to me at shawn@smrstrategic.com.

ETFs, and Why They’re Better

ETFs usually have lower fees and more options than traditional mutual funds, while offering more avenues of diversification, opportunity, and far superior tax-loss harvesting options.  This is why I use ETFs and individual securities for my clients.

For most of the 20th century, traditional mutual funds were accepted by investors as the best investment products for building wealth and diversification.  In 1993, a new kid on the block came in and changed the investment landscape forever.  That’s when SPY, the SPDR S&P 500 ETF, was introduced to the world.  Global investment in ETFs now totals nearly $10 trillion.

ETFs are typically more cost effective and tax efficient than their older sibling, mutual funds.  The investments held inside both of these types of funds can be the exact same, but the tax adjusted returns can vary dramatically.  Both funds can buy and sell securities throughout the year that create capital gains or losses within the fund.  With mutual funds, those gains or losses are passed on to the investor in the calendar year that each individual security was sold.  Typically, in December of each year, mutual fund owners will receive their capital gains or losses reports.  These can sometimes be shocking.  In the stock market selloff of 2022, the S&P 500 was down about 18%, yet many mutual fund owners were given large tax bills because investments within the fund were sold in the year 2022. 

When it comes to ETFs, capital gains taxes are only paid when you sell the ETF.  There are no yearly capital gains or losses, like with mutual funds.  You will have capital gains when you sell your ETF, but you will have more options as to when you pay those taxes. You can also possibly find capital losses somewhere else that you can match those off with.  If you hold onto these ETFs until you pass away, you will never have to pay that capital gains tax and your heirs will receive those funds at a stepped-up basis.  Their new cost basis will be the value of the fund on the day that you died.

 

Tax-Loss Harvesting

Ticker SymbolInvestmentSharesPrice PaidCurrent PriceValueGain/Loss
SPYS&P 500 ETF50300498$24,900$9,900
AAPLApple Stock100130188$18,800$5,800
TAT&T Stock5003117$8,500$-7,000
MSFTMicrosoft Stock50200414$20,700$10,700
XLUUtilities ETF2007360$12,000$-2,600
Total$84,900$16,800

Let’s say that you bought 5 different investments over the past several years.  You may want to sell your SPY ETF, but you would have to pay capital gains taxes on $9,900.  The long-term capital gains rate is 15%, that means that you’d have to pay $1,485 in taxes.  Using a tax-loss harvesting method, you could also sell your AT&T and Utilities stocks that have losses of $7,000 and $2,600 respectively.  You can subtract that $9,600 loss from your $9,900 gain.  You now only have a gain of $300, and owe only $45 in capital gains taxes. ETFs allow for a much better opportunity of using tax-loss harvesting to improve your tax-adjusted returns.

InvestmentGain/LossPotential Tax
SPY$9,900$1,485
T$-7,000$-1,050
XLU$-2,600$-390
Total$300$45

In qualified accounts, such as 401ks and IRAs, the tax-loss harvesting effect is less important because you don’t pay capital gains taxes.  You will have to pay ordinary income taxes on the money when you withdraw it from the account.  You will also have to account for which gains are long-term and which are short-term.  Short-term gains are taxed as ordinary income, but again, ETFs make for easier tax-loss harvesting.

It’s Not What You Make, It’s What You Take Home

Wallet

What should I do with money that I don’t want to risk in the stock market?  That is one of the most common questions that I hear.  Interest rates are higher now than they’ve been in about 15 years.  This brings opportunity.  You can now walk into your local bank and buy a CD or put your money in a money market and earn a few percent interest on your money.  Easy, right?  Well, without knowing your options, you may be missing out on better returns.

CDs and Corporate bonds are taxed as ordinary income, meaning that you pay federal and state taxes.  If you fall in higher tax brackets, your federal tax rate may be up to 37%.  State income taxes vary state by state.  It’s not uncommon for states to have state income taxes higher than 7%.  California tops the list at 12.3% for its highest earners.  However,  Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas, Washington, Wyoming, Tennessee, and New Hampshire all have no state income tax. 

You don’t have to pay federal income tax on municipal bonds.  For most states, if you own municipal bonds in the state where you live, you don’t have to pay state income tax on the interest.  Illinois, Iowa, Oklahoma, and Wisconsin currently make you pay state income tax on that interest, no matter what municipal bonds you buy, with a few exceptions. 

After-Tax Bond Returns

I used A-Rated corporate and municipal bonds for this exercise to try to make it as apples to apples as I could.   In the first example, the after-tax returns on the CDs, corporate bonds, and Out-of-State Municipal bonds are all about the same.  The in-state municipal bonds are the best option.

This second example is a bit extreme, but it does go to show how much taxes can eat away at your returns.  Even though the CDs and corporate bonds have higher current yields, the municipal bonds are the best option, especially California municipal bonds.

Keep in mind, this is only for money that’s held in non-retirement accounts.  In retirement accounts, such as IRAs, Roth IRAs, 401Ks, and 403Bs, interest is not taxed.  The preferential tax treatment of municipal bonds is useless in these accounts.  For these accounts, it’s best to choose the higher pre-tax returns. These calculations differ depending on what tax bracket you are in and what state you live in.  There are also some cities and other municipalities that have separate income taxes as well.  This also assumes that you can find a CD that pays a nationally competitive rate.  Too often people will walk into their bank and purchase whatever CD that their bank is offering.  A quick online search of a handful of banks shows that they are currently offering 2.5% to 5.3%. It’s best to shop around.